Does Jay Gibbons Deserve A Second Chance?

Jay Gibbons has been out of baseball since his release from the Baltimore Orioles back in Spring Training. Gibbons was mentioned in the Mitchell Report, and then was canned by Baltimore for reasons related to baseball performance.”

Jay Gibbons has since sent out a letter to all 30 MLB teams, asking for a second chance. I am posting this letter below. Read it and see what you think? Does he deserve a second chance? If you ran a baseball organization, would it be worth taking a risk on him?

“All I need is a chance”The following is the full text of a letter written by former Orioles outfielder Jay Gibbons to all 30 major league teams, seeking a minor league contract. Gibbons, who was named in the Mitchell report, has been without a job since Baltimore released him in March.

Writing this letter is both painful and humiliating. It has been almost six weeks since my release from the Orioles and I am still unable to land any opportunity at a second chance to play the game that I love.

I am young, healthy and determined. I have acknowledged and apologized for the mistake that I made and writing this letter should be proof enough that I have indeed suffered for my mistake.

I have faith and hope that some team will give me the chance to prove that I can not only be a productive player but also be a stellar member of their organization. My faith in a second chance has inspired me to work harder than I have at any time in my life. My faith has gotten me through this most difficult period in my life.

All I need is a chance — any chance — anywhere. I am more than willing to begin the process of proving that I can and will be a productive major league player by playing in the minor leagues.

As you know, I have played seven seasons in the big leagues and have hit 20-plus homeruns in three seasons and have hit .277 in three seasons (2003, 2005 and 2006). At 31 years old, I have NO DOUBT that my best baseball is ahead of me.

I know that my agents at ACES have tried to land me an opportunity in the minor leagues but have been met with negative responses by each and every Organization. I am not blind to the fact that I have made a mistake and that mistake has raised doubt about my character and ability. It is important that you know that my indiscretions, while regretful, were made in an effort to heal a nagging wrist injury. I would encourage you to speak with anyone in this game, including players, coaches, front office etc. who know me. I am confident that everyone you speak with will vouch for my character.

I respectfully and humbly request that you grant me the chance to play for your organization.

I am so willing to prove myself as a player, and a person, that I will donate ALL of my minor league earnings to your Club’s charity. In the event that I earn the right to play at the major league level, I will gladly donate a significant sum to that same charity.

Once again, all I need is a chance and I will prove that I can be an extremely productive player and a great addition to your organization.

Please feel free to contact me directly [phone numbers redacted].

Thank you for your time and consideration.


Jay Gibbons



4 thoughts on “Does Jay Gibbons Deserve A Second Chance?

  1. I think someone should give him a second chance.
    It’s not as if he hurt someone else. Other sports give criminals second chances, why not a guy who made a mistake?

  2. Why not give him a chance? Gibbons is no different than a lot of the other major league players, who have recieved second chances to play in the league again, i.e. Sammy Sosa. If all he is asking for is a chance to prove himself in the Minor Leagues then so be it. If he fails then he was a productive of performance enhancements, but if he does then he would show that maybe his best baseball is still in front of him.
    But I don’t see how the “powers that be” not give him another chance, when they knowing let these problems exsist in baseball in the first place.
    A minor league contract is peanuts, especially when it comes to taking a risk on someone who knows what it takes and has been at the major league level.

  3. I agree. Why is it that someone like Steve Howe can be suspended SEVEN times, and keep coming back, and Jay Gibbons is left in the dugout?

  4. Steve Howe was a left handed reliever with a great fastball. OK outfielders, we got plenty of those.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s